When I first started fly fishing 40 years ago—for largemouth bass and trout—the prevailing attitude about fly reels was that they were the least important part of the fly fishing ensemble, nothing more than a tool to hold your fly line. As I evolved as a fly fisherman—branching out into the saltwater and fishing for bigger trout and bass—it became readily apparent that the old dogma was just plain wrong. Finding the best fly reel—one that is durable and has a good drag system—is absolutely essential to success during your time on the water.
It’s no coincidence that my evolution in thinking corresponded with huge technological advances in fly reels. In the past decades, fly reels have been manufactured with space age materials, adding to the durability, and the drag systems have become smoother, more reliable and much stronger.
It’s hard to go wrong these days when buying a fly reel. We’re in the golden age, for sure. But I’ve winnowed down a list of the fly reels that I use now or have tested in the past for all sorts of different fish to help you make an informed buying decision.
Best Fly Reel Overall: Mako 9600B
Key Features
- Carbon-fiber drag system
- 15.2 ounces
- Four different color options
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best overall fly reel because it will last forever—your grandkids will use this reel.
Pros
- Smooth drag
- A drag lock, which means you’ll always know how much pressure you’re applying on a fish
Cons
- It’s among the priciest reels on the market
- Heavy for its category
Product Description
Mako was originally founded by an aerospace engineer named Jack Charlton, a true pioneer in the fly reel world. The reel is made to last a few lifetimes. Its carbon-fiber drag system is a giant upgrade over the cork drags that are found in many reels—it’s smoother and sturdier. And the reel’s interior parts are completely sealed, so it needs only a quick rinse even after getting dunked in the saltwater.
The Mako is the preferred reel of some of the top tarpon anglers of today, like Nathaniel Linville and David Magnum, prized for its toughness, reliability and ability to fight big, hard-charging fish. The drag lock allows the angler to fight fish with confidence: Any given setting always exerts the same amount of drag pressure. The only drawback (besides its hefty price tag) is weight: The Mako is heavier by a few ounces than other reels in its category.
Key Features
- 5.6 ounces
- Made of aluminum bar stock
- Two colors
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best reel for trout because it picks up line quickly, balances well, and is durable.
Pros
- Huge arbor that picks up line faster than just about any reel in its class
- Durability
Cons
Product Description
The Mirage II is a big part of the reason that the Manchester, Vermont-based Orvis Company has experienced a recent renaissance in reel-making. The Mirage’s weight is perfect—it balances your trout rod and feels great in your hand. The extra-large arbor enables you to reel in your line extremely quickly. You won’t always need to be able to do that when fishing for trout, but it can be a day-saver if you hook into a really big one.
You’re going to bang around your reel while trout fishing, but the Mirage will hold up, both structurally and cosmetically, thanks to its aluminum bar stock body and anodized finish. One nice little thing the Mirage features is a rounded reel foot. Most reels have reel feet with edges, which can feel uncomfortable to the touch and produce kinks in your leader if you wrap it around the reel foot (as I do) when moving to a new bit of water. The rounded reel foot solves both of those problems.
Best Fly Reel for Saltwater: Tibor Riptide
Key Features
- 9 ounces
- All internal parts are sealed
- Many different color options
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best reel for saltwater because nearly 1,000 world records have been caught with Tibor reels.
Pros
- Strong drag system
- Incredibly durable
- Low maintenance
Cons
- Arbor is smaller than other reels in its class
Product Description
Tibor’s founder and owner is the Hungarian-born tool-and-die maker, Ted Juracsik. He’s the OG when it comes to well-built fly reels, having made his first in the early 1970s. Juracsik’s credo has long been “the most beautiful machines have the least moving parts.” His reels live up to it: They are simple and excellent.
I have fished my Riptide for more than 20 years now for a wide variety of different species, including striped bass, snook, permit, bonefish, tarpon and Atlantic salmon. I have enjoyed every minute I’ve used the reel. It’s tough as nails, has a great drag and is nearly maintenance-free (after fishing in the salt, a quick rinse with freshwater is a good idea). Some anglers may prefer the super large arbors on some of the more modern reels, but I’ve never had a problem retrieving line quickly with my Tibor.
Key Features
- 4.65 ounces (in 5-weight)
- Two colors
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best budget fly reel because it offers serious high-end performance at an entry-level price.
Pros
- Excellent drag system
- Inexpensive
Cons
- Not great in saltwater
- Can get banged up cosmetically
Product Description
I bought my first Lamson Liquid reel many years ago as a backup for my salmon-fishing outfit. Over the years, I’ve found myself using it almost as much as I do the first team reel. The Liquid, which comes in 3-through-9-weights, is die-cast and not machined like most high-end reels, which is why the price is so low (it’s cheaper to manufacture that way).
But you don’t lose much in performance here, or even in durability, though I have found that the reel is easily nicked-up cosmetically. The drag system is the same one that Lamson uses in some of its high-end reels, so nothing is compromised there. The only real drawback is that I’ve had trouble in the saltwater with this reel—machined bar stock reels tend to hold up better in that hostile environment. But for your freshwater needs? An excellent backup, or even primary, reel, especially for those new to the sport.
Best for European Nymphing: Sage ESN
Key Features
- 4.9 ounces
- One-size-fits-all (2-5 weights)
- Two colors
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best reel for European nymphing because it’s purpose built, offers customizable balance, quickly picks up line, and there are no line-catching gaps in the reel.
Pros
- A larger-than-usual arbor so you can get a fish on the reel as fast as possible
- A full frame so you won’t get your line or leader stuck in the reel
- Three weights included (.5 ounces, 1 ounce and 1.5 ounces) so you can balance the reel to your rod
Cons
- A highly-specialized, one-trick-pony reel. You wouldn’t want to use it for anything but European nymphing.
Product Description
European nymphing for trout has exploded in popularity in recent years, primarily because, when done right, it can be a deadly tactic for catching them. Part of doing it right is having the correct equipment, and the ESN is the best reel I’ve found for European nymphing. It has an extra large arbor, which allows you to easily get the slack out of your line and get the fish on the reel quickly.
The full frame construction of the reel (basically, no gaps) is essential—your leader and the thinner lines used in the discipline can easily slip through any gaps in your reel and foul up your day. And the easy-to-install weights that come with the rod allow you to balance out your reel to your rod, whether you’re using a 2-,3-,4-, or 5-weight. Though the ESN should not be used for conventional fly fishing, it’s the only one you’ll need for European nymphing.
Key Features
- 10.8 ounces (in 8-weight)
- Carbon-fiber drag system
- Five colors
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best fly reel for drag strength because the ultra-strong drag feels like it could stop a speeding 18-wheeler.
Pros
- Extremely strong drag (16 pounds in the 8-weight; 30 pounds in the 12-weight)
- Very affordable
Cons
- The drag is not sealed, which means it needs maintenance
Product Description
The Behemoth’s carbon-fiber drag system is super strong. You won’t need its strength for a largemouth bass or most trout. But if you fish for hard-charging species that need to be stopped—say, snook who lurk near mangroves or giant trevally anywhere—this reel is an excellent option. The great thing about the drag is that it’s smooth, as well. You won’t lose any fish because of any hitches as the line leaves the reel.
The Behemoth just looks tough, too, beefy and solid. And it is, in fact, very sturdy, even though it is die-cast and not machined. Its one drawback is its weight: A 10.8-ounce 8-weight reel is a lot to handle.
Best Fly Reel for Spey/Switch Rods: Loop Opti Strike
Key Features
- 9.3 ounces (in 9-weight)
- Machined aluminum parts
- One color
Why It Made the Cut
This lightweight, high-performance reel is the best fly reel for Spey and switch rods because it has a large arbor for quickly picking up line and has a nice drag system.
Pros
- An extremely large arbor
- Narrow frame
- Excellent drag
Cons
- Not a full frame, so line may occasionally slip into the reel
- A bit too big for a one-handed rod
Product Description
Another fast-growing trend in recent years in fly fishing is the use of two-handed rods. Spey rods are for two-hands only. Switch rods, in theory, can be cast with one or two hands. As with European nymphing, it’s important to get your gear right if you are going to get into the two-handed game. The reel is hugely important.
Loop has been a mainstay in two-handed rod fishing for decades, and with the Opti Strike, the company has reached the apex of its two-handed reel design. The reel has a huge arbor that allows for quick retrieval of line. That’s important because you will have a ton of line out when casting a two-handed rod. The frame, though not full, is narrow enough that you usually don’t have to worry about your line slipping through it. Loop’s Power Matrix drag system is among the best in the industry, and comes in handy when that hot steelhead you’ve hooked is rocketing downstream for the next pool.
Key Features
- 9.9 ounces (in 12-weight)
- Sealed drag
- Two colors
Why It Made the Cut
This is the best fly reel for big game because it can stop the biggest beasts in the ocean and serve you for decades.
Pros
- Extremely large arbor means great retrieval speeds
- Vents on the reel help dry out backing
Cons
- Drag can be difficult to adjust mid fight
Product Description
The Monster has been a popular reel among those who fish for the ocean’s largest fly rod fish—billfish, giant trevally, tuna, sharks, and tarpon—ever since its release a decade ago. Its drag is one of the strongest in its class.
Its huge arbor, known as a “Giga” arbor, retrieves between 14 and 15 inches per turn, which is remarkable. The giant arbor also allows you to load a lot of backing on your reel, which is a good thing to have when fighting truly huge fish. The reel comes with an innovative venting system that dries out the backing quickly, so you won’t have to worry about rotting. The Monster is made with nearly indestructible CNC machined aluminum, which is important given the abuse the reel will inevitably take in the ocean.
Best for Aesthetics: Abel Vaya
Key Features
- 5.45 ounces (in 5/6 weight)
- Dual-pawl drag system
- More than 80 different color/design options
Why It Made the Cut
If you want the best fly reel for aesthetics, you can’t do better than this stunning reel.
Pros
- Lightweight
- Priced reasonably for its performance if you don’t spring for a specialized design
Cons
- The designs—some of which are quite unconventional—may not appeal to some traditionalists
Product Description
It used to be that fly reels pretty much came in two colors: black or silver. Not anymore. In recent years, most companies have begun to offer reels in different colors and/or designs. Though traditionalists may scoff at the trend (they can still get their black or silver reels), the new colors and designs have made the sport a bit more fun. Aesthetics, after all, have always been a part of fly fishing.
To my mind, no one does the color/design thing better than Abel. They’ve been innovative with colors for a while, and have recently begun to incorporate designs from well-known fly fishing artists, like Derek DeYoung, Andrea Larko, and Casey Underwood. All you have to do is pick your color or design when ordering a reel (colors will run you an extra $125; artist’s designs cost an extra $800).
The good news is that Abel also makes great reels. The Vaya is among my favorites. It’s light and has a good drag system. It’s also half-ported on one side, which is an interesting design element in itself, and means the reel doesn’t need any counterweights bolted to it.
Key Features
- 4.32 ounces (in 6-weight)
- Click-and-pawl drag
- One color
Why It Made the Cut
If you like the sound of a click-and-pawl drag but want a design with modern features, then check out Hardy Marquis LWT.
Pros
- Lightweight
- Classic look, feel and sound
Cons
- Does not have a large arbor
Product Description
Hardy has been making fly fishing gear since the late 1800s. The Marquis was long a mainstay within the trout and Atlantic salmon worlds, known for its looks and the unique sound the reel made when a fish made a run and pulled line from it. As space age material infiltrated reel manufacturing, the Marquis fell out of favor, and Hardy stopped making them.
But in 2016, the Marquis was reintroduced, with some upgrades. There is no longer a line guide on the reel, which would have been cumbersome with modern lines. The frame is no longer full, either, which means you can fit more line on the reel. And there’s more porting on the reel, which allows for better line drying.
What hasn’t changed: the classic look and the old-fashioned click-and-pawl drag, which is the fly fishing world’s equivalent of a manual transmission (disc drags would of course be automatic transmissions). Click-and-pawl drags take some getting used to—when fighting bigger fish, you have to use your palm to slow down the reel. But this is part of the fun. If you’re going to go old-school with this elegant reel, you might as well go full-hog.
FAQs
Q: How much does a good fly reel cost?
A quality fly reel can cost between $70 and $1,700.
Q: Does fly reel color matter?
The color of a fly reel won’t help you catch more fish or the reel function. But, a great looking reel like an Abel will enhance pride of ownership and your enjoyment on the water.
How to Choose a Fly Reel
There are a few significant things to consider when you look for a fly reel: Your budget, the type of water you’ll be fishing and the species of fish you will be targeting. Unfortunately, there is no one reel that can cover everything. Trout and bass can be targeted, generally speaking, with 3-6 weight reels. For bigger saltwater fish, you’ll need a 7-12 weight reel. A big tarpon cannot be angled with a 5-weight reel. Likewise, a half-pound bream would be no fun on a 12-weight reel—it’d be like bringing a cannon to a spitball contest.
One thing that should not factor into your buying decision: Your skill level. Any fly reel you buy should be looked at like an investment. A good one will last you decades. A great one will last a lifetime—or more.
Final Thoughts
Right now, consumers are in the golden age of fly reels with a ton of great options on the market. Hopefully, this list will help you match your fishing to a reel. Remember: It’s always a good idea to visit a store and get a look at a reel and even attach it to a rod to see how it feels in your hand.
Read Next: Best Fly Rod: Catch Any Fish on a Fly
Credit: Source link
